May 3, 2024

Top Lawyer

Think Phenomenal Law

California braces for possible political earthquake- POLITICO

With help from Eli Okun and Garrett Ross

Today, seven states hold primaries: Iowa, Mississippi, Montana, New Jersey, New Mexico, South Dakota and California.

What should you be watching for? The day’s biggest news will likely come from the Golden State, where voters are poised to make major statements about the directions of their respective parties.

IN CALIFORNIA …

The Republicans: 

The big question: how large DONALD TRUMP looms in the party.

Races to watch: GOP Reps. YOUNG KIM and DAVID VALADAO are facing close primaries in swing districts with pro-Trump candidates nipping at their heels.

The national relevance: “A loss by either would be a disaster for Republicans,” as Dems see the battleground seats as potential pickup opportunities, Lara Korte, Alex Nieves and Ally Mutnick write in their curtain-raiser this morning. “[JOE] BIDEN won both of those districts in 2020 — running up a 13-point margin in Valadao’s seat. Democrats are targeting both districts and would much rather face [their opponents] than the two incumbents, who have large campaign accounts and known crossover appeal.”

The Democrats:

The big question: whether “tough on crime” politics is making a comeback among Democratic voters. Write Lara, Alex and Ally: “Concerns about the rising rates of homicide, assault and property crime have put an uncomfortable spotlight on California’s Democratic leaders, who in recent years have favored policies that reduce sentencing and aim to lower the population of overcrowded prisons.”

Races to watch: There are two in particular …

— The Los Angeles mayoral primary is all but certain to set up a November general election between two Democratic candidates: longtime Rep. KAREN BASS, a progressive, and billionaire businessman RICK CARUSO, a former Republican who has outspent everyone in the race by several orders of magnitude. Bass has advocated more community-based crime prevention programs, while Caruso has proposed posting an additional 1,500 law enforcement officers on the street and requiring people to move from homeless encampments to shelter beds.

— San Francisco’s D.A. recall election: In 2019, CHESA BOUDIN was elected district attorney “on promises to reform San Francisco’s criminal justice system — by increasing police accountability and shifting away from policies that disproportionately fill jails and prisons with poor people and people of color,” write S.F. Chronicle’s Tara Duggan and Ricardo Cano. “But a sizable, vocal contingent of San Franciscans is seeking to unseat him Tuesday, in the belief that those policies are too lenient and have made San Francisco a more dangerous place to live and work.”

The national relevance: “An earthquake is building in Tuesday’s California elections that could rattle the political landscape from coast to coast,” CNN’s Ronald Brownstein writes in an excellent look at the stakes. “In Los Angeles and San Francisco, two of the nation’s most liberal large cities, voters are poised to send stinging messages of discontent over mounting public disorder, as measured in both upticks in certain kinds of crime and pervasive homelessness. …

“Linking both these contests … is a widespread sense among voters in both cities that local government is failing at its most basic responsibility: to ensure public safety and order. … Tuesday’s California results will likely send a stark message to the Democrats controlling Congress and the White House. The outcome will again underscore how much danger a party in power can face when voters feel that certainty has been stripped from their lives — a dynamic that extends beyond crime and homelessness to inflation, soaring gasoline prices and continued disruption from the unending Covid pandemic.”

WHAT ELSE YOU SHOULD KNOW …

— The big picture: “A true battleground map comes into view” with today’s primaries, write NYT’s Jonathan Weisman and Shawn Hubler. “In most of the country, congressional redistricting shored up incumbency for both parties. Tuesday will showcase much of the battleground that remains. Of the 53 House seats that the nonpartisan Cook Political Report sees in play, nine are in California, New Mexico and Iowa.”

— A different kind of Trump test: Last year, 35 House Republicans voted to create a bipartisan commission to investigate the Jan. 6 attack at the Capitol; five of them are on the ballot today. And though Trump promised retribution for any Republican who dared cross him, he hasn’t played quite as big a role in today’s primaries as he has in the other marquee matchups this cycle.

That might be good news for those five — especially Rep. DUSTY JOHNSON, the two-term South Dakota Republican who is battling a challenge from state Rep. TAFFY HOWARD, who has spread Trump’s lies that the 2020 election was stolen. (Notably, Johnson also voted to keep Wyoming Rep. LIZ CHENEY in her GOP leadership post.) Another incumbent to keep your eyes on: Rep. MICHAEL GUEST, the only member of the Mississippi delegation who voted for the Jan. 6 commission, who is fighting off two Trumpian challengers.

If the five get through today with their nominations intact, it could be yet another signal that Republican voters aren’t always going to take marching orders from Trump.

Good Tuesday morning. Thanks for reading Playbook. Drop us a line: Rachael Bade, Eugene Daniels, Ryan Lizza.